Recipe: Havarti Mac and Cheese
A classic recipe with a classy twist; mac and cheese won’t get old if you whip up this tasty version
October 7, 2020
Mac and cheese is one of those foods you can find in just about every restaurant — even if it’s just on the kid’s menu — with all sorts of takes: baked, fried, served on a burger, served with protein, spicy and sweet. The possibilities are endless. I, for one, am a traditionalist that prefers my mac and cheese not baked, with a lot of cheddar and no breadcrumbs.
I do like a huge stack of green onions on it, though.
Anyways, as much as I love my go-to Kraft Spirals mac and cheese, I decided it was time to figure out how they make it as good as they do in the restaurants.
Enter: the roux.
Roux is a mix of melted butter and flour that you add to a sauce to thicken it. Normally, you add an even ratio of flour to melted butter — for example, 1 tbsp flour in 1 tbsp of butter — and chill it before adding to your milk. This will make your mac and cheese sauce thick and creamy instead of milky or stringy from cheese.
I do want to warn you against using shredded cheese for mac and cheese recipes in the sauces. The shredded cheese has a finishing agent to keep it fresher longer, and that makes for a weirdly oily and textured cream sauce It is as gross as it sounds. If you want to opt for easy measuring, sliced cheese is a great option and does not result in weird oils and textures.
Making a roux has changed my mac and cheese game, and I really hope all you mac and cheese fanatics out there try this out and up your game, too.
Havarti and Cheddar Mac and Cheese Serves 4
Ingredients:
- ½ box of pasta, or 8 oz
- 4 tablespoon butter or margarine
- 3-4 tablespoons flour
- I personally like less flour which makes it a little thinner.
- ½ cup milk, heated
- 2 oz Havarti cheese, cubed
- I like to add Havarti because the flavor is similar to cheddar enough that it still tastes like cheddar mac and cheese, but it is a little creamier and aides in the creaminess of the sauce.
- 3 oz Cheddar cheese, cubed
- Optional: Green onions
Recipe:
- Boil water and cook pasta until tender
- Melt butter in a saucepan over medium-low heat
- Gradually add in flour, stirring consistently
- Note: The consistency when you use butter vs margarine will be different.
- Gradually stir in milk until completely combined
- Note: As mentioned above, you traditionally chill the roux before adding milk. I, however, am lazy and did not notice a difference between the outcomes of a chilled roux and a warm roux.
- Add cubed or sliced cheese, and stir frequently as it melts
- Note: If at any point the roux and milk mixture’s texture changes to something not creamy (you’ll know), your sauce has broken. The oil, flour and milk are no longer working together. I have personally found that increasing the heat a little and stirring faster tends to save it.
- Optional: add a pinch of your favorite seasonings, like garlic powder, onion powder and cayenne
- Toss with pasta
- Optional: top with green onions